Baking With Cacao Buttons: A Substitution Chart

Cacao buttons substitute for chocolate chips or a chopped bar gram for gram. They do not substitute for cocoa powder, and that is the swap people get wrong: a Chaski button is 77% cacao, so most of its weight is cacao solids plus cocoa butter, while cocoa powder has had most of that fat pressed out of it. Once you know that, cacao baking substitution is mostly a question of fat, sugar and temperature.

Recipes make this harder than it needs to be by measuring in cups. A cup of chips and a cup of buttons are not the same weight, because flat discs stack differently from teardrops. Weigh everything instead.

The substitution chart

What the recipe asks for Swap in What changes
100 g dark chocolate chips 100 g buttons Buttons spread into seams rather than holding a round shape. Chop them to roughly 5 mm if you want distinct pieces.
100 g 70-85% bar, chopped 100 g buttons, as they are Almost nothing. Buttons arrive already piece-sized, so you skip the chopping board.
100 g chocolate for melting into a batter 100 g buttons, melted over water Nothing, provided you keep the bowl off the boil.
100 g couverture for a coating or shell 100 g buttons, melted and tempered A coating is the one job where you have to control the crystal form, not just the heat.
100 g cocoa powder No direct swap You would be adding fat and sugar the recipe has not accounted for, and removing the dry bulk it needs.

For the cocoa powder row, the honest answer is to change recipe rather than ingredient. If you want to understand why the two forms are not interchangeable in the first place, we have written that up separately in the difference between raw cacao and cocoa powder.

Cacao baking substitution starts with a melting point

Cocoa butter does not have one melting temperature. It crystallises into six different forms, and each one melts somewhere different. Chen, Ghazani, Stobbs and Marangoni, Chen et al., Nature Communications, 2021, set out two published sets of figures for forms I to VI: one at 17.3, 23.3, 25.5, 27.5, 33.9 and 36.3 °C, and an older set at 13, 20, 23, 25, 30 and 33.5 °C. Form V, the one confectioners aim for, sits at 33.9 °C on the first set and 30 °C on the second.

Two caveats before you use those numbers. They are figures for cocoa butter and for the laboratory chocolate in that paper, not for a finished 77% button with coconut sugar and mushroom extracts in it, and the two source sets disagree by nearly 4 °C on form V alone. So treat them as the shape of the problem rather than a specification.

The shape of the problem is this. A fan oven at 180 °C takes every one of those forms past melting within a couple of minutes, so a button in a cookie dough is fully liquid long before the crumb has set. It only becomes solid again as the tray cools back below roughly 34 °C, which is why it re-sets as a seam in the shape of whatever gap it was sitting in. Nothing has gone wrong. That is the material behaving normally.

The same paper attributes bloom, that grey-white film on re-set chocolate, to an uncontrolled change from form V to form VI, and reports that chocolate left to crystallise statically at 23 °C or 26 °C ended up with poor surface and mechanical properties. For anything baked, bloom is cosmetic. For a shell, it is the reason tempering exists.

Coconut sugar does not behave like caster sugar

Chaski buttons are sweetened with coconut sugar, so a swap changes the sugar in the recipe as well as the fat. Saraiva, Carrascosa, Ramos, Raheem, Lopes and Raposo, Saraiva et al., International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 2023, review the published analyses and report 2-3% moisture for coconut sugar, with one Indonesian HPLC analysis giving 57.05% sucrose alongside 6.97% glucose and 5.45% fructose in a preserved sample.

That is a review collating single-origin analyses rather than a specification, and the figures vary widely between the studies it gathers. What survives the caveats is still useful: coconut sugar is not pure sucrose. If your tray is colouring sooner than the recipe says, drop the oven 10 °C before you shorten the time.

The practical correction is simpler. Buttons bring their own sugar. If the recipe assumed unsweetened or 100% chocolate, take sugar out of the recipe rather than adding it back later.

What is actually in a Chaski tube

The tube holds 600 g of 77% dark buttons. The cacao is single-origin, from Peru and Ecuador, and it is ground at low temperature. Alongside it: coconut sugar, Lion's Mane as a fruiting body extract, and Cordyceps sinensis mycelium. The Ginkgo Biloba component is being replaced by 200 mg of Tremella fuciformis, a 10:1 fruiting body extract, per daily dose, and that change is in progress rather than settled. There are no emulsifiers, no seed oils, no palm oil and no added cane sugar, and every batch is tested for lead, cadmium and pesticides. The button shape changed in mid-2026; the recipe did not change with it. The dose printed on the pack is four buttons.

One thing we will not tell you: what a 180 °C oven does to those extracts. We have not measured it, so we will not guess in either direction. A full tube is £44.99 for the 600 g Chaski Cacao tube, and if you want to know how the buttons taste before you commit a batch of them to a bake, what ceremonial cacao tastes like covers the bitterness and the finish.

Next step: take your usual brownie recipe, convert every chocolate line to grams, and drop the oven 10 °C on the first attempt. The rest of our method pages are collected in the Chaski guides index.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use cacao buttons instead of chocolate chips?

Yes, gram for gram. The difference is shape, not chemistry. Chips are often formed to hold a point in the oven, whereas a flat button melts and then re-sets into whatever seam it was lying in, so your cookies end up with ribbons rather than dots. If you want distinct pieces, chop the buttons to roughly 5 mm before folding them in and chill the dough for twenty minutes so the pieces start from cold. If you want ribbons, fold the buttons in whole and do nothing else. Both are correct outcomes; they are just different textures.

Can I replace cocoa powder with cacao buttons?

Not directly. Cocoa powder is what is left after most of the cocoa butter has been pressed out, so it works in a recipe as a dry ingredient with bulk and no significant fat. A 77% button is mostly cacao solids and cocoa butter, plus coconut sugar. Swapping one for the other adds fat and sugar the recipe never accounted for and removes the dry weight it needed, which usually shows up as a greasy, dense bake that will not rise. If a recipe is built on cocoa powder, use cocoa powder and add buttons as a separate inclusion instead.

Why did my melted buttons set with a grey film on top?

That is bloom. Chen et al., 2021, attribute it to cocoa butter changing from one crystal form to another after it has set, and the result is a greyish-white film on the surface. It is a crystal structure, not mould, and it is not a sign the chocolate has spoiled. Avoiding it means controlling cooling rather than just melting carefully, which is what tempering is. For a baked item it does not matter and you will never see it under a crumb. For a coating or a shell, where the surface is the point, you need a tempering protocol.

Do I need to reduce the sugar when I swap buttons in?

Often yes. Chaski buttons are sweetened with coconut sugar, so if your recipe was written around 100% chocolate or unsweetened cocoa, the buttons bring sweetness the recipe did not expect. Take the sugar out of the recipe rather than trying to balance it later. If you are swapping for ordinary 70% chips the gap is much smaller and most bakes tolerate it without adjustment. The other thing worth adjusting is the oven: coconut sugar is not pure sucrose, so if your tray is colouring sooner than the recipe says, dropping the temperature 10 °C is a reasonable first move.

Sources

  1. Chen J, Ghazani SM, Stobbs JA, Marangoni AG, Nature Communications, 2021
  2. Saraiva A, Carrascosa C, Ramos F, Raheem D, Lopes M, Raposo A, International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 2023
Liquid error (sections/pagefly-section line 6): Could not find asset snippets/pf-6bdf23d6.liquid