Cacao Bedtime Drink: The Recipe In Grams And Degrees
Four buttons, 200 ml of liquid at about 60 °C, whisked hard for thirty seconds. That is the whole cacao bedtime drink recipe, and everything below it is an argument for those three numbers rather than the ones you will see elsewhere.
Most versions of this drink online start by bringing milk to the boil. That is wrong twice over, once for the chocolate and once for the milk, and both reasons are measurable. One is a melting point. The other is a foam.
The recipe, in grams and degrees
You need four Chaski buttons, which is the dose printed on the tube, and 200 ml of whichever liquid you are using. A pinch of fine salt is optional and makes a noticeable difference to how the bitterness lands. Nothing else is required.
- Heat the 200 ml to roughly 60 °C. Without a thermometer: steam rising steadily, no bubbles breaking the surface, and the pan is still comfortable to hold a hand above.
- Take it off the heat. Drop the four buttons in and leave them for sixty seconds without stirring.
- Whisk for thirty seconds. A small balloon whisk or a cheap milk frother both work; a spoon does not, and you will see unmelted flecks if you try.
- Taste. If it is too bitter, the usual fix is the salt, not more sugar.
Timing matters more than technique. Buttons dropped into liquid that is still on the heat will scorch against the base of the pan before they disperse. Off the heat first, then the chocolate.
Why 60 °C and not boiling
Cocoa butter melts a long way below boiling. Chen, Ghazani, Stobbs and Marangoni, Chen et al., Nature Communications, 2021, set out two published sets of melting points for cocoa butter's six crystal forms: 17.3 to 36.3 °C in one, and 13 to 33.5 °C in the other. Even taking the highest figure in either set, 36.3 °C, a mug at 60 °C is already well past the point where every crystal form has gone liquid.
Those are figures for cocoa butter and for the laboratory chocolate in that paper, not for a 77% button with coconut sugar in it, and the two sets disagree by nearly 4 °C on the form confectioners actually aim for. The direction of travel is clear enough regardless: there is nothing above 60 °C that melting needs, so the extra heat buys you nothing and costs you the next paragraph.
What it costs is foam. Kamath, Huppertz, Houlihan and Deeth, Kamath et al., International Dairy Journal, 2008, foamed cows' milk across 5 to 85 °C and found skim milk foams were most stable when formed at 45 °C. They also report that milk fat worked against both foam formation and foam stability, most noticeably between 15 and 45 °C, and that homogenisation and UHT treatment reduced that effect. Whole milk foams had smaller bubbles but ruptured more through coalescence.
Two limitations worth stating. That work used cows' milk only, so it says nothing about oat or almond, and the published abstract gives the 45 °C optimum without the underlying foam volumes. Still, it gives you a practical sequence rather than a guess: melt at 60 °C, let the mug drop to somewhere nearer 45 to 50 °C, and do the final whisk there if a head of foam is the point. If it is not the point, whisk straight away and drink it hot.
Oat, water or whole milk
| Liquid | What it does to the taste | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Water, 200 ml | The clearest read on the cacao itself. Thin body, long bitter finish. | Separation on standing. Whisk again before the second half of the mug. |
| Whole cows' milk, 200 ml | Rounder and noticeably less bitter. Thicker on the tongue. | The fat works against a stable foam, per Kamath et al. |
| Oat, 200 ml | Sweeter before you add anything, because of the drink's own sugars. | Formulations differ a lot between brands. Test yours once. |
| Half water, half milk | The compromise most people land on after a week. | Nothing in particular. It is forgiving. |
If you want the bitterness mapped out before you start adjusting, what ceremonial cacao tastes like goes through the finish in more detail, and how the four-button dose is arrived at explains where that number on the tube comes from.
What is in the tube
600 g of 77% dark buttons. The cacao is single-origin, from Peru and Ecuador, and ground at low temperature. With it: coconut sugar, Lion's Mane as a fruiting body extract, and Cordyceps sinensis mycelium. The Ginkgo Biloba component is being replaced by 200 mg of Tremella fuciformis, a 10:1 fruiting body extract, per daily dose, and that change is in progress. No emulsifiers, no seed oils, no palm oil, no added cane sugar. Every batch is tested for lead, cadmium and pesticides. One tube is £44.99 for the 600 g Chaski Cacao tube, or £32.99 per tube if you buy three at once.
What this page deliberately does not do is tell you what a mug of chocolate will do to your evening or your night. That is not something we have measured, so it is not something we are going to put in writing. The method is the part we can stand behind.
Next step: make it once with water and once with whole milk on consecutive nights, same four buttons, same 200 ml, and keep the one you prefer. The rest of our method pages sit in the Chaski guides index.
Frequently Asked Questions
What temperature should the milk be for a cacao bedtime drink?
Around 60 °C for melting, then let it fall to roughly 45 to 50 °C if you want foam. The melting figures in Chen et al., 2021, put every cocoa butter crystal form below 36.3 °C, so 60 °C is already generous and anything hotter adds nothing. Kamath et al., 2008, found cows' milk skim foams were most stable when formed at 45 °C, which is why the two jobs want slightly different temperatures. Without a thermometer, aim for steady steam and no bubbles breaking the surface, then wait a minute before the final whisk.
Can I make it with water instead of milk?
Yes, and water is the better choice if you want to taste the cacao itself. It gives a thinner body and a longer bitter finish, because there is no fat and no milk sugar rounding it off. The trade-off is separation: a water-based mug will start to settle after a few minutes, so whisk it again halfway down. A pinch of fine salt shifts the bitterness more in water than in milk. Half water and half milk is where a lot of people end up once they have tried both ends.
How many buttons go in one mug?
Four, which is the dose printed on the Chaski tube, in 200 ml of liquid. That ratio gives a drink with real body rather than a thin cocoa. Scaling up is linear, so a 400 ml mug takes eight buttons, but the whisking time goes up more than you would expect because there is more fat to disperse. Using fewer than four in 200 ml tends to taste watery rather than simply milder. If you prefer it lighter, keep four buttons and add more liquid rather than cutting the chocolate down.
Can I make this in a microwave or a blender?
Both work with one adjustment each. In a microwave, heat the liquid on its own first, then add the buttons off the heat, because microwaving chocolate and liquid together heats unevenly and you will get scorched patches. In a blender, let the liquid drop below about 60 °C before you lid it, since hot liquid builds pressure and can push the lid off. A blender also incorporates more air than a whisk, so you will get a thicker head and a slightly lighter body in the mug.
Sources
- Chen J, Ghazani SM, Stobbs JA, Marangoni AG, Nature Communications, 2021
- Kamath S, Huppertz T, Houlihan AV, Deeth HC, International Dairy Journal, 2008