Cacao Buttons vs Cacao Powder: Which Format To Buy

The short version: cacao powder has had most of its cocoa butter pressed out, and a cacao button has not. That single mechanical step is what makes a powder disperse in hot water and a button melt into it, and it is also why the two have very different fat figures on the back of the pack.

Everything else people argue about is downstream of that press. Start with the fat and the rest falls into place.

The press is the whole difference

Whole cocoa beans are roughly half fat. Mattilsynet's Norwegian food composition table puts cocoa beans at 51.9 g of fat per 100 g. Grind them and you get a liquid mass; put that mass in a hydraulic press and the cocoa butter comes out as one stream and a dry cake stays behind. Mill the cake and you have cocoa powder.

USDA FoodData Central lists unsweetened cocoa powder at 13.7 g of fat per 100 g, with 19.6 g protein, 37 g fibre, 1.75 g total sugars, 499 mg magnesium and 2060 mg theobromine. Those are figures for the commodity in a reference database, not for anything we sell.

A button never goes through that press. The cocoa butter that was in the bean is still in the disc, which is why it sets hard in a cupboard and goes soft in a warm hand.

What the law fixes, and what it leaves open

Schedule 1 of The Cocoa and Chocolate Products (England) Regulations 2003 defines cocoa powder as the product of cleaned, shelled, roasted beans converted to powder, containing not less than 20% cocoa butter calculated on dry matter and not more than 9% water. Below 20% butter, the reserved description changes to fat-reduced cocoa or fat-reduced cocoa powder.

So the fat number on a bag of powder is a category marker, not a quality signal.

The same schedule says nothing about the word cacao, which appears nowhere in it. If a bag says cacao rather than cocoa, no additional standard has been met.

Alkalisation only happens to powders

Dutching, or alkalisation, treats cocoa with an alkali to darken the colour and soften the acidity. It is a powder-side process and it is measurable. Miller and colleagues, writing in the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry in 2008, surveyed commercial cocoa powders and reported total flavanols of 34.6 mg/g in natural powders, 13.8 mg/g in lightly alkalised, 7.8 mg/g in medium and 3.9 mg/g in heavily alkalised, with the figures falling as extractable pH rose.

That is a survey of products on the market rather than a controlled trial, so the powders differed in origin and processing as well as in pH, and the standard deviations were wide. We are describing what the chemists measured in the powder, and nothing beyond that. The longer write-up sits in our data page on alkalisation and flavanol loss.

The two USDA entries show the processing line too: the natural powder record lists 37 g fibre, 1520 mg potassium, 2060 mg theobromine and 230 mg caffeine per 100 g, while the alkali-processed record lists 29.8 g fibre, 2510 mg potassium, 2630 mg theobromine and 78 mg caffeine. These are separate commercial samples, not the same batch tested twice, so read them as two records rather than a before-and-after.

Cacao vs cacao powder as a daily drink

  Cacao powder Cacao buttons (Chaski)
Cocoa butter Pressed out, 20% minimum to be called cocoa Still in the disc
May be alkalised Yes Not applicable
Making a drink Whisk or blend, clumps in cold liquid Melts in hot liquid, stir
Sweetener Usually added by you Coconut sugar, already in
Portion Scooped Counted: 4 buttons on the pack
Eat it dry No Yes
Storage Dry cupboard, long shelf life Cool cupboard, softens in heat

In a kitchen the difference shows up in the washing up. Powder needs a whisk, a blender or a very determined fork, and an unsweetened powder needs something sweet adding or it is a hard drink to finish. Buttons go into a mug, hot liquid goes on top, and the fat they carry does the emulsifying that a powder drink is always fighting for.

Powder wins on baking: it disperses into flour and recipes are written for it. If you are choosing between all three formats, the nibs, powder and buttons comparison puts them side by side.

What is in a Chaski tube

Chaski Cacao is a 600 g tube of 77% dark buttons, made from single-origin Peruvian and Ecuadorian cacao that is ground at low temperature. The sweetener is coconut sugar: no added cane sugar, no emulsifier, no palm oil, no seed oil. Lion's Mane is included as a fruiting body extract and Cordyceps as sinensis mycelium. The recipe is in transition, with Ginkgo Biloba being replaced by 200 mg Tremella fuciformis (10:1 fruiting body extract) per daily dose, so read the panel on the batch you receive.

Every batch is tested for lead, cadmium and pesticides. The daily dose on the pack is four buttons. A tube is £44.99, carries a 30-day money-back guarantee, and UK orders placed before 4pm are dispatched the same day. We do not ship to Albania.

We publish no flavanol or magnesium figure for Chaski, because no one has measured one for this recipe. The numbers above are commodity figures from USDA and Mattilsynet, and they are not our product's.

How to choose, in one paragraph

If you bake, or you want to control the sweetener yourself, buy a powder, and look at whether it says natural or alkali-processed before you look at anything else. If you want a countable portion and a drink that comes together with a spoon, buy buttons. More comparisons like this one are indexed on the Chaski guides page.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is cacao powder the same as a cacao button, just ground?

No. A button keeps the cocoa butter that was in the bean, and a powder does not. Powder is made by pressing the ground mass so the butter comes out, then milling the dry cake that is left. USDA FoodData Central lists unsweetened cocoa powder at 13.7 g of fat per 100 g, while Mattilsynet lists whole cocoa beans at 51.9 g. That press is also why a powder needs whisking into liquid and a button simply melts.

Can I make a drink with cacao buttons instead of powder?

Yes, and it needs less equipment. Put the buttons in a mug, add hot water or hot milk of any kind, and stir until the mass has gone. Chaski's pack gives a daily dose of four buttons, so the portion is the same each time without weighing. Powder gives you more control over sweetness, since most powders are unsweetened and you decide what goes in; buttons arrive sweetened with coconut sugar at 77% dark.

What does alkalised or Dutch-processed mean on a cocoa powder?

It means the cocoa was treated with an alkali during processing, which darkens the colour and lowers the acidity. Miller and colleagues, in the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry in 2008, surveyed commercial powders and measured total flavanols of 34.6 mg/g in natural powders against 3.9 mg/g in heavily alkalised ones, falling as pH rose. That was a market survey rather than a controlled trial, so the samples differed in other ways too.

Does cacao powder contain more caffeine than chocolate?

The databases record both theobromine and caffeine in cocoa powder: USDA lists 2060 mg theobromine and 230 mg caffeine per 100 g for the unsweetened natural powder, and 2630 mg and 78 mg for the alkali-processed entry. Those are two different commercial samples rather than one batch measured twice. Any finished chocolate dilutes those figures with sugar and cocoa butter, and we do not publish a measured figure for Chaski.

Which is better value, powder or buttons?

They are priced for different jobs, so compare them per use rather than per 100 g. Powder is cheap per gram but is usually an ingredient that needs a sweetener, a liquid and a whisk. Buttons cost more per gram because the cocoa butter has not been pressed out and the sweetener is already in. A 600 g Chaski tube is £44.99 and carries a 30-day money-back guarantee on a full tube; current pricing for other formats is on the product page.

Sources

  1. US Department of Agriculture, FoodData Central, SR Legacy 169593, Cocoa, dry powder, unsweetened
  2. US Department of Agriculture, FoodData Central, SR Legacy 169594, Cocoa, dry powder, unsweetened, processed with alkali
  3. Mattilsynet, Matvaretabellen (Norwegian Food Composition Table), 2023, entry 09.175 Cocoa beans
  4. The Cocoa and Chocolate Products (England) Regulations 2003, SI 2003/1659, Schedule 1
  5. Miller et al., Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 2008, 56(18), 8527-8533
Liquid error (sections/pagefly-section line 6): Could not find asset snippets/pf-6bdf23d6.liquid