Cacao vs Kola Nut: What The Published Analyses Actually Measured

Cacao and kola nut are both seeds, both traditionally chewed or ground rather than brewed, and both carry methylxanthines — the small chemical family that includes caffeine and theobromine. The split between those two compounds is where the comparison actually lives: published analyses of chocolate report theobromine as the dominant methylxanthine with caffeine low, while published analyses of kola seed put caffeine front and centre.

What almost nobody writing about cacao vs kola nut will tell you is that the kola figures are shakier than they look. The percentages that get quoted around the internet are mostly relative peak areas from a mass spectrometer, not milligrams per gram of seed. That distinction changes what you are allowed to conclude.

What the published kola nut analyses actually measured

Start with the most detailed one. Adesanwo and colleagues, in the Journal of Exploratory Research in Pharmacology in 2017, worked on Cola nitida seed collected from a single site, the Alaro Farm Settlement at Ile-Ife in Nigeria, under voucher FPI 2052. They extracted 40 g in duplicate, used 2 kg for the isolation, and ran pyrolysis GC-MS, derivatised GC-MS and ESI-MS.

Caffeine came out at 22.3% of the pyrolysate from whole seed and 5.2% from the already-extracted seed, and at 17.9% of the methanol extract by derivatised GC-MS. Theobromine was 1.8% in whole seed and 1.0% in extracted seed by the same pyrolysis method. Caffeine was isolated from the ethyl acetate fraction, melting point 230–233 °C.

Now the limitations, because they are load-bearing. Those are relative percentages of a chromatogram or an extract, not concentrations in the seed, and caffeine was never calibrated against a standard. The paper's own text and tables disagree twice (22.5% versus 22.3%; 3.85% versus 2.95%). Pyrolysis burns the sample, so part of what the detector sees is a degradation product. One site, one species.

A 2026 paper in Frontiers in Nutrition by Alshehri and colleagues repeated the pattern on kola seeds bought from a market in Jeddah: caffeine at 18.52% of one GC-MS fraction and 81.59% of another after silylation, catechin and epicatechin at 33–41% of two further fractions, theobromine identified but never quantified. One batch, no replicates, no calibration, and the authors call their own findings preliminary.

Cacao vs kola nut: the methylxanthine picture

Cacao has been measured more carefully, mostly because chocolate is a larger industry. Meng, Jalil and Ismail, in Molecules in 2009, ran reversed-phase HPLC on defatted commercial chocolate from Kuala Lumpur and reported 883.11 ± 3.54 mg of theobromine per 100 g in dark chocolate, 125 mg per 100 g in milk chocolate, and below the detection limit in white. They did not measure caffeine at all, and they did not report cocoa percentage — a real gap, since methylxanthine content tracks cocoa mass.

For caffeine in chocolate, the nearest analytical reference is Tokusoglu and Ünal in European Food Research and Technology in 2002, who ran isocratic RP-HPLC on 11 chocolate products and summarised caffeine as low in all samples while theobromine was high. Eleven products, abstract only: a direction, not a number.

Cacao Kola nut
Botanical part Fermented, dried seed of Theobroma cacao Seed of Cola nitida or Cola acuminata
Dominant methylxanthine reported Theobromine Caffeine
Best-quantified figure available 883.11 mg theobromine per 100 g dark chocolate (HPLC, Meng 2009) 22.3% of pyrolysate, relative (Py-GC-MS, Adesanwo 2017)
Absolute mg/g figures published? Yes, by HPLC against standards Largely no — relative percentages dominate
Usual retail format Bar, button, powder, nib Whole or split nut, powder, extract
Taste Bitter, fruity or nutty depending on origin and roast Bitter and astringent, softening as it is chewed

Why a quoted percentage is not a dose

Here is the practical consequence. "22% caffeine" sounds like a dose and is not one. It is a share of chromatogram peak area under one method, and the same paper gets 5.2% from the same seed after extraction and 1.7% by a third route. No multiplying by a nut's weight.

Caffeine intake, by contrast, is something regulators have put actual figures to. The European Food Safety Authority's 2015 opinion on the safety of caffeine concluded that single doses up to 200 mg, around 3 mg per kg of body weight, and daily intakes up to 400 mg, around 5.7 mg/kg, do not raise safety concerns for healthy adults, with 200 mg a day the figure cited for pregnant women. That is a risk assessment of a compound, not a statement about either seed — and you cannot apply it to a kola nut whose caffeine content has never been quantified in milligrams.

If you want the cacao side of that question in detail, we cover whether cacao contains caffeine at all and the difference between theobromine and caffeine as molecules separately.

What a Great Britain label is allowed to say about either

Both seeds sit under the same rule. Only claims authorised on the Great Britain nutrition and health claims register, published by the Department of Health and Social Care and last updated on 19 May 2026, may be used here. The register is a list, not a verdict on whether an ingredient is interesting. If a claim is not on it, it does not go on a pack or a page, however many papers exist.

That is why this guide stops at composition. The kola literature is thin, uncalibrated and single-site, and unauthorised claims are not available anyway. Two independent reasons to describe rather than promise.

What is actually in a Chaski tube

Chaski is not a kola product and does not contain kola nut. It is a 600 g tube of 77% dark chocolate buttons, built on single-origin Peruvian and Ecuadorian cacao that is low-temperature ground, sweetened with coconut sugar, with Lion's Mane as a fruiting body extract and Cordyceps sinensis mycelium. Ginkgo Biloba is being replaced by 200 mg of Tremella fuciformis, a 10:1 fruiting body extract, per daily dose. The daily dose on the pack is four buttons.

There are no emulsifiers, no seed oils, no palm oil and no added cane sugar. Every batch is tested for lead, cadmium and pesticides. The cacao comes from a Peruvian farm the founder has visited and whose farmers he has met. It is not certified, so that word is not on the pack. A single tube is £44.99. You can read the full ingredient breakdown on the Chaski Cacao product page, and the rest of this library sits at our guides index.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does kola nut have more caffeine than cacao?

The published analyses point that way, but they do not let you say by how much. Adesanwo and colleagues reported caffeine at 22.3% of the pyrolysate from whole Cola nitida seed in 2017, against theobromine at 1.8%, so caffeine is clearly the dominant methylxanthine in kola. In chocolate the order is reversed, with Meng and colleagues measuring 883.11 mg of theobromine per 100 g of dark chocolate by HPLC in 2009 and Tokusoglu and Unal describing caffeine as low across 11 chocolate products in 2002. The problem is that the kola figures are relative percentages from uncalibrated methods on single-site samples, so they cannot be converted into milligrams per nut.

What does cacao taste like next to kola nut?

Different kinds of bitter. Fermented, roasted cacao carries fruit and nut notes alongside its bitterness, and the origin changes the balance noticeably, which is why single-origin labelling exists at all. Raw kola seed is bitter and astringent in a flatter, more tannic way, and chewers report it softening as the chewing goes on. Cacao is also eaten with sugar and cocoa butter alongside it, which blunts the edge, whereas kola is usually chewed as the plain seed. No lab settles this, since bitterness perception varies between people.

Why are kola nut composition figures so inconsistent?

Because of how they were produced. Most published percentages are relative peak areas from gas chromatography-mass spectrometry rather than concentrations calibrated against a caffeine standard, so the number depends on the method, the fraction and the derivatisation step. Adesanwo and colleagues reported 22.3%, 5.2%, 17.9%, 2.95% and 1.7% for caffeine from the same seed by five different routes in 2017, and their own text and tables disagree in two places. Pyrolysis methods also burn the sample, so part of what the detector records is a breakdown product rather than what was in the seed.

Does Chaski Cacao contain kola nut?

No. The tube contains single-origin Peruvian and Ecuadorian cacao, coconut sugar, Lion's Mane fruiting body extract and Cordyceps sinensis mycelium, with Ginkgo Biloba being replaced by 200 mg of Tremella fuciformis, a 10:1 fruiting body extract, per daily dose. There is no kola nut, no emulsifier, no seed oil, no palm oil and no added cane sugar. The buttons are 77% dark, the cacao is low-temperature ground, and every batch is tested for lead, cadmium and pesticides. The daily dose printed on the pack is four buttons from a 600 g tube.

Sources

  1. Adesanwo JK, Ogundele SB, Akinpelu DA, McDonald AG, Journal of Exploratory Research in Pharmacology, 2017
  2. Alshehri A and colleagues, Frontiers in Nutrition, 2026
  3. Meng CC, Jalil AMM, Ismail A, Molecules, 2009
  4. Tokusoglu O, Unal KM, European Food Research and Technology, 2002
  5. European Food Safety Authority, EFSA explains risk assessment: caffeine, 2015
  6. Department of Health and Social Care, Great Britain nutrition and health claims (NHC) register, 2026
Liquid error (sections/pagefly-section line 6): Could not find asset snippets/pf-6bdf23d6.liquid