Why Coconut Sugar And Not Cane
Chaski uses coconut sugar and not cane sugar for one reason that survives scrutiny: flavour. Coconut sugar carries a caramel, slightly smoky note that sits against a 77% cacao base differently from the flat, sharp sweetness of refined sucrose, and the recipe was built around that.
Before anything else, the thing most pages in this category will not say. Coconut sugar is sugar. It is not a health food, it is not a free pass, and we are not going to imply otherwise on a page selling chocolate. If you are avoiding sugar, a 600 g tube of 77% dark buttons sweetened with coconut sugar is still a sweetened product and you should treat it as one.
Why coconut sugar and not cane: what it tastes like
Refined cane sugar is close to pure sucrose, and pure sucrose tastes of one thing. That is useful in a bar built to be mass-pleasing and much less useful in a 77% chocolate, where the cacao is already doing something complicated and bitter and you want the sweetener to meet it rather than mask it.
Coconut sugar is not refined to the same point. It is a concentrated palm sap, and the colour and the caramel character come from what the refining never removed. In a dark chocolate that means the sweetness arrives with a toffee edge rather than as a clean hit, which is why a 77% made with coconut sugar reads as less austere than a 77% made with cane at the same percentage. That is a sensory claim about chocolate, nothing more.
It also matters that Chaski's cacao is ground at low temperature rather than roasted hard and alkalised. A low-temperature grind keeps more of the original bean character, bitterness included, and a one-note sweetener against that is a waste of the bean.
How coconut sugar is actually made
The production route is worth knowing, because "coconut sugar" sounds like it comes from the fruit and it does not.
Sap is taken from the unopened flower cluster of the coconut palm. Workers cut the inflorescence and collect the sap that runs from it over roughly eight to twelve hours, sometimes adding lime to stop it fermenting before it reaches the pan. The sap is then boiled, traditionally for around three hours at 100–110 °C, and stirred until it thickens and crystallises; the crystals are hand-selected and sieved. Industrial producers often swap the open pan for rotary evaporation at around 250 mbar and 60 °C (Saraiva et al., International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 2023).
That same review compiles composition data from several national studies and the numbers vary a great deal between them — one set of Indonesian samples reports sucrose at roughly 49–57%, while figures from other countries are reported on different bases entirely. It is a review of other people's measurements rather than a controlled comparison, so the honest summary is that coconut sugar is predominantly sucrose and that published figures differ by origin and method. Nobody should be quoting a single precise number for it, us included.
Coconut sugar against the alternatives, on our terms
| Sweetener | What it is | Why Chaski does not use it |
|---|---|---|
| Refined cane or beet sugar | Near-pure sucrose, bleached and crystallised | One-dimensional against a 77% cacao base |
| Coconut sugar | Concentrated coconut palm sap, boiled and crystallised | This is what Chaski uses |
| Stevia or monk fruit | High-intensity plant sweeteners | Lingering aftertaste and no bulk to build a chocolate around |
| Maltitol and other polyols | Sugar alcohols used in "no added sugar" confectionery | Cooling mouthfeel we did not want in a 77% |
| No sweetener at all | 100% cacao | A different product; most people will not eat it daily |
The polyol row is the one worth dwelling on. A large part of the "no added sugar" chocolate shelf is built on maltitol, which lets a pack carry a reassuring front-of-pack message while changing the texture of the chocolate underneath it. We would rather use a sugar, name it on the label, and let you decide. For more on the general comparison, see coconut sugar versus refined sugar in chocolate and how coconut sugar compares with cane sugar.
What the label says and does not say
Chaski's ingredient list reads coconut sugar, with no added cane sugar. That is a composition statement and it is the whole of the statement. We do not make a glycaemic, nutritional or metabolic argument for coconut sugar anywhere on the pack or on these pages, because the evidence base is thinner than the marketing around it and because a chocolate brand making that argument about its own sweetener should not be trusted by default.
What we will say is what we left out. No emulsifiers, no seed oils, no palm oil, no added cane sugar. A 77% chocolate with a short ingredient list is not a nutritional position; it is a formulation discipline, and you can check it against the panel rather than taking our word for it.
What is in the tube
600 g of 77% dark buttons. Single-origin Peruvian and Ecuadorian cacao, coconut sugar, Lion's Mane as a fruiting body extract, and Cordyceps sinensis mycelium. Ginkgo Biloba is being replaced by 200 mg of Tremella fuciformis, a 10:1 fruiting body extract, per daily dose. The pack dose is four buttons. Every batch is tested for lead, cadmium and pesticides. One tube is £44.99.
One flavour note that belongs here: the current extract is less bitter than earlier batches, so a tube bought now tastes sweeter than one bought a year ago, with no change to the amount of coconut sugar in the recipe. Check the live panel on the Chaski Cacao product page, and the rest of the ingredient series in the guides index.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does Chaski use coconut sugar instead of cane sugar?
For flavour. Coconut sugar carries a caramel, faintly smoky character that refined cane sugar does not, and a 77% cacao base is bitter and complex enough that a one-note sweetener fights it rather than balancing it. Chaski's recipe was built around that interaction, alongside a low-temperature grind that keeps more of the bean's original character. It is a formulation decision about taste. We make no nutritional or metabolic argument for coconut sugar, on the pack or anywhere else.
Is coconut sugar still sugar?
Yes. Coconut sugar is predominantly sucrose, the same sugar that makes up refined cane sugar, and it should be counted as sugar in anything you are tracking. A review of published coconut sugar analyses noted that reported figures vary widely between producing countries and measurement methods, which is a reason to distrust any single precise number quoted for it. Chaski is a sweetened dark chocolate. If you are avoiding sugar, that is the relevant fact and no sourcing detail changes it.
How is coconut sugar made?
Not from the coconut itself. Sap is collected from the unopened flower cluster of the coconut palm, running for roughly eight to twelve hours after the inflorescence is cut, with lime sometimes added to prevent fermentation. The sap is then boiled down, traditionally for about three hours at 100–110 °C, and stirred until it crystallises, after which the crystals are hand-selected and sieved. Industrial producers often use rotary evaporation at around 250 mbar and 60 °C instead of an open pan. The description comes from a 2023 review in the International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health.
Why not use stevia, monk fruit or a sugar-free sweetener?
Because of texture and taste rather than principle. High-intensity sweeteners such as stevia and monk fruit provide no bulk, so a chocolate built on them needs a bulking agent to replace the missing sugar, and in our tasting they left an aftertaste that a dark chocolate does nothing to hide. Sugar alcohols such as maltitol, which underpin much of the "no added sugar" confectionery shelf, change the mouthfeel in a way we did not want. We would rather use a sugar and name it plainly on the label.
Does coconut sugar make Chaski taste sweeter than other 77% chocolate?
It makes it taste different rather than simply sweeter. The caramel note reads as rounder and less austere than the same percentage sweetened with refined cane sugar, which some people describe as sweeter even at the same sugar content. There is a separate reason a recent tube may taste sweeter than an older one: the current batch uses a less bitter extract than earlier batches. That is a change in one component of the blend, not a change in how much coconut sugar is in the recipe.