Why There Are No Emulsifiers In Chaski

There are no emulsifiers in Chaski because the recipe does not need one. No soya lecithin, no sunflower lecithin, no PGPR, no E476 of any kind: the ingredients are cacao, coconut sugar and the mushroom and botanical extracts, and nothing else is added to make them behave.

That sounds like a small thing. It is not, because an emulsifier in chocolate is rarely about the eating experience. It is about making a thick liquid flow faster through a factory, and about how much expensive cocoa butter you can take out before the chocolate stops moulding properly.

What an emulsifier actually does in chocolate

Molten chocolate is sugar and cocoa particles suspended in fat. How easily it pours is described by two numbers: plastic viscosity, which is how thick it is once it is moving, and yield stress, which is the push needed to get it moving at all. Lecithin and PGPR are the two levers the industry uses to move those numbers.

Pombal and colleagues, writing in Molecules in 2024, measured both on an industrially manufactured chocolate with 48% cocoa. They raised soya lecithin in 0.2% steps from the factory baseline of 0.3% up to 1.1%, and raised PGPR from 0.2% up to 0.8%. Plastic viscosity fell as lecithin went up, levelled off at around 0.6%, and stopped improving after that. Yield stress rose roughly linearly with lecithin across the whole range. A small addition of PGPR pulled yield stress down sharply.

Two caveats worth keeping. It is a rheology and texture study on one industrial formulation in one laboratory, not a comparison of finished products on a shelf, and at the higher PGPR levels the measured yield stress approached zero, so the rheometer could not resolve viscosity reliably. It tells you what these additives do to flow. It does not tell you anything about the person eating the chocolate.

Why a 70% bar still carries lecithin

Here is the tension the category does not advertise. Cocoa butter is typically the most expensive ingredient in a bar of dark chocolate. It is also what makes it flow. A few tenths of a per cent of lecithin thins the mass enough that a manufacturer can run with less cocoa butter and still fill a mould cleanly at speed, which is why you find lecithin in bars at every price point, including ones with a serious cocoa percentage on the front.

None of that is illegal, hidden or sinister. It is a cost and throughput decision, declared on the ingredients list exactly as the rules require. But it is a decision made for the machine, and once you know that, "contains emulsifier (soya lecithin)" reads differently.

The other half of the same trick: added vegetable fat

Emulsifiers travel with a second allowance. Under the Cocoa and Chocolate Products (England) Regulations 2003, a product sold as chocolate may contain up to 5% of vegetable fats other than cocoa butter, drawn from six named fats listed in Schedule 2: illipe, palm oil, sal, shea, kokum gurgi and mango kernel. Schedule 1 sets the floor for the reserved description "chocolate" at 35% total dry cocoa solids, of which at least 18% must be cocoa butter and at least 14% dry non-fat cocoa solids.

If those fats are used, Regulation 6(1)(b) requires the statement "contains vegetable fats in addition to cocoa butter", and Regulation 7(2) says where it has to sit: in the same field of vision as the ingredients list, clearly separated from it, in bold lettering no smaller than the list, near the reserved description. It is one of the few sentences on a chocolate wrapper whose placement is written into law. Most shoppers have never noticed it.

Additive What it is for In Chaski
Soya or sunflower lecithin (E322) Lowers plastic viscosity so the mass flows at speed No
PGPR (E476) Lowers yield stress so the mass starts moving under less force No
Added vegetable fats, up to 5% Cocoa butter substitute within the six permitted fats No
Palm oil One of the six permitted fats in Schedule 2 No
Added cane sugar Bulk sweetener No, coconut sugar instead

What leaving them out costs on the production line

An unemulsified mass at 77% cacao is stiff. It has to be ground at low temperature and then handled patiently, and it will not be rushed through a mould the way a thinner, lecithin-assisted mass will. The buttons are made by a UK manufacturer, and production may move to Peru in future.

The clearest illustration is the button itself. In mid-2026 the shape changed. The recipe did not: same cacao, same coconut sugar, same extracts, same percentage. What changed was the geometry that an untreated mass of this thickness forms reliably at the volume we now make. If the formula carried lecithin, the shape would have been a free choice. Without it, the chocolate gets a vote.

If you want the wider version of this argument, the guide on how ceremonial cacao is made covers grinding and conching, and what ceremonial cacao tastes like covers the texture end of it. The full index sits at the Chaski guides library.

What is actually in a Chaski tube

A 600 g tube of 77% dark buttons. Single-origin Peruvian and Ecuadorian cacao, low-temperature ground, from a farm our founder has visited and whose farmers he has met. Coconut sugar rather than cane. Lion's Mane as a fruiting body extract and Cordyceps sinensis mycelium. Ginkgo Biloba is being replaced by 200 mg of Tremella fuciformis, a 10:1 fruiting body extract, per daily dose, so check which formulation the tube you receive carries. The dose printed on the pack is four buttons.

No emulsifiers, no seed oils, no palm oil, no added cane sugar. Every batch is tested for lead, cadmium and pesticides. The current price is £44.99 for one 600 g tube; the full ingredients panel is on the Chaski Cacao product page.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is soya lecithin in chocolate a problem?

Soya lecithin is a permitted additive, declared on the ingredients list, and used in chocolate at fractions of a per cent to change how the molten mass flows. Our reason for leaving it out is formulation, not a verdict on the additive: a 77% mass ground at low temperature and sold as buttons does not need a flow modifier, so the recipe runs without one. If you avoid soya for your own reasons, the practical point is simply that it is not in the tube.

Does chocolate without emulsifiers taste different?

Texture differs more than flavour. Without lecithin the mass is thicker in the mould, and the finished button carries more of the cacao particle structure, so it breaks rather than bends and melts a little more slowly on the tongue. Flavour comes mostly from the beans, the roast and the grind rather than from the absence of an additive. Chaski is 77% with coconut sugar, so it reads as properly dark and slightly caramel rather than sharp. The most recent batch uses a less bitter extract, which makes it taste sweeter than earlier ones.

What does "contains vegetable fats in addition to cocoa butter" mean on a wrapper?

It means up to 5% of the fat is not cocoa butter. The Cocoa and Chocolate Products (England) Regulations 2003 allow six named fats in that slot: illipe, palm oil, sal, shea, kokum gurgi and mango kernel. If a manufacturer uses any of them, Regulation 6(1)(b) makes that statement compulsory, and Regulation 7(2) requires it in bold, in the same field of vision as the ingredients list and no smaller than it. It is a legally placed disclosure, so it is worth reading. Chaski uses none of those fats.

Is PGPR the same thing as lecithin?

No. They act on different parts of the same problem. Lecithin mainly reduces plastic viscosity, the thickness of the chocolate once it is already flowing. PGPR mainly reduces yield stress, the force needed to start it flowing. The 2024 Molecules study found lecithin lowered plastic viscosity up to about 0.6% and then stopped, while a small PGPR addition cut yield stress sharply. Industrial formulations often use both, at different jobs. Chaski uses neither, so the ingredients list has no E numbers on it at all.

Sources

  1. The Cocoa and Chocolate Products (England) Regulations 2003, legislation.gov.uk, 2003
  2. Pombal M, Marcet I, Rendueles M, Diaz M, Molecules, 2024
Liquid error (sections/pagefly-section line 6): Could not find asset snippets/pf-6bdf23d6.liquid