Lion's Mane vs Cordyceps: What Each One Actually Is
Lion's Mane and Cordyceps are not close relatives and are not interchangeable. Lion's Mane is Hericium erinaceus, a white toothed fungus that fruits on dead hardwood and is eaten as a vegetable; Cordyceps is a genus of fungi that grow out of insects, and almost nothing in the two life cycles lines up.
The comparison most pages attempt is which one is better for you. That one cannot be made here: there are no authorised GB health claims for either fungus. So this page compares what is on the label and in the bag — species, tissue, the compound a lab can measure, and the number most sellers leave off.
Two fungi that are not related
Lion's Mane is easy to recognise: a cascade of white spines hanging off a log, bruising yellow with age, sold as a culinary mushroom in Britain. One commercially relevant species, no taxonomic argument.
Cordyceps is messier. Sung and colleagues published a phylogenetic reclassification of the clavicipitaceous fungi in Studies in Mycology in 2007 that broke the old genus apart. Cordyceps militaris stayed put as the type species of Cordyceps. The caterpillar fungus of the Tibetan plateau was moved out and recombined as Ophiocordyceps sinensis, on page 46 of that paper.
So a label that says only "Cordyceps" has told you very little. Two genera answer to the word in everyday use.
Lion's Mane vs Cordyceps: the label questions worth asking
| Question | Lion's Mane | Cordyceps |
|---|---|---|
| Species on the label | Hericium erinaceus. One species, no ambiguity. | Cordyceps militaris or Ophiocordyceps sinensis. Ask which. |
| Part used | Fruiting body or mycelium. Must be stated. | Fruiting body, mycelium, or a grain-grown biomass. |
| Eaten as food? | Yes, commonly, cooked like a vegetable. | No. Sold dried, extracted or as biomass. |
| Marker compound a lab can quantify | Beta-glucan, by difference. | Cordycepin, by HPLC. Beta-glucan, by difference. |
Fruiting body or mycelium decides what you are buying
The fruiting body is the mushroom. Mycelium is the thread network that comes before it, and in commercial production it is grown on sterilised grain and harvested with the grain still attached, because separating the two is impractical at scale.
That matters because of what a glucan assay does. McCleary and Draga set out the reference approach in the Journal of AOAC International in 2016: release total glucan by controlled sulphuric acid hydrolysis, measure starch and glycogen separately with glucoamylase, and report beta-glucan as the difference between the two. Starch is a glucan. Grain is starch. If the subtraction is not done, grain reads as polysaccharide.
Vetter's 2023 review of mushroom glucans in Foods collects what comparisons exist. In the shiitake dataset it reports, mycelium carried the lowest total glucan of the three tissues, at a mycelium to cap to stipe ratio of 100 to 161.7 to 199.6, and the highest relative share of alpha-glucan. It is a narrative review of other people's numbers, the sample size behind the mycelium figures is not stated, and shiitake is not Lion's Mane or Cordyceps.
A "10:1 extract" line does not close the gap. It is a yield ratio: ten units in, one out. It describes the arithmetic of the process, not the composition of the result.
Cordycepin: the one number that separates the two Cordyceps
Su and colleagues published an HPLC method with fluorescence detection in Analytical Methods in 2019 and ran it on commercially purchased caterpillar-fungus material. Cordyceps militaris measured 0.735 mg of cordycepin per gram. In the Cordyceps sinensis material, cordycepin was not detected at all.
That is an analytical chemistry paper, not a clinical one: three replicates, shop-bought samples, no biological outcome measured. But the point is clean. These are not the same raw material. Our guide to the difference between Cordyceps sinensis and militaris takes it further.
What the Lion's Mane research actually did
The trial everybody paraphrases is Mori and colleagues, Phytotherapy Research, 2009. Thirty Japanese adults aged 50 to 80, all with mild cognitive impairment defined by a screening score of 22 to 25 out of 30, were randomised double-blind to Lion's Mane or placebo. Twenty-nine completed.
The dose was four 250 mg tablets three times a day for sixteen weeks: 3,000 mg of tablet daily, each tablet 96% air-dried powdered fruiting body. On the study's 30-point scale the mushroom group scored higher than placebo at weeks 8, 12 and 16, and scores fell back four weeks after dosing stopped.
The limitations are substantial, and the authors state several. The placebo group improved too, which they put down to test familiarity. It is unknown whether the proposed active compounds reach human brain tissue. Twenty-nine people, one country, four months, not replicated at that size. Note the form as well: roughly 2.9 g of plain dried powder a day, not a concentrated extract, so the figure is not comparable to a few hundred milligrams of extract in anything. That is a description of one trial. It is not a statement about any product, and not a statement about you.
Reading the two ingredient lines side by side
A usable label gives four things per mushroom: Latin binomial, tissue, milligram weight per stated daily portion, and measured beta-glucan with the method named. Most give one or two. The long version is in how to read a supplement or functional food label, and the dosing conventions people meet in practice are in how much Lion's Mane people take.
What is in a Chaski tube
Chaski Cacao is a 600 g tube of 77% dark chocolate buttons, four buttons to the daily dose on the pack. The cacao is single-origin Peruvian and Ecuadorian, low-temperature ground, sweetened with coconut sugar. No emulsifiers, no seed oils, no palm oil, no added cane sugar. Every batch is tested for lead, cadmium and pesticides.
On the two mushrooms in question: the Lion's Mane is a fruiting body extract, and the Cordyceps is Cordyceps sinensis, mycelium. Not militaris. Ginkgo Biloba is being replaced by 200 mg of Tremella fuciformis, a 10:1 fruiting body extract, per daily dose. One honest gap: there is no measured beta-glucan figure for Chaski, so we do not print one, and by the standard set out above you should treat any brand that prints a polysaccharide percentage instead as having told you nothing. A single tube is £44.99. The full breakdown sits on the Chaski Cacao product page, and the rest of the library is at our guides index.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Lion's Mane and Cordyceps the same kind of mushroom?
No. Lion's Mane is Hericium erinaceus, a toothed fungus that fruits on dead hardwood and is cooked and eaten as a vegetable in Britain. Cordyceps is a genus of fungi that colonise insects, and since Sung and colleagues reclassified the group in Studies in Mycology in 2007 the caterpillar fungus has sat in a separate genus, Ophiocordyceps, from the type species Cordyceps militaris. They are not close relatives, they are not grown the same way, and the compounds a laboratory measures in each are different.
What does a 10:1 extract ratio actually tell me?
It tells you the yield of the process and nothing else: ten units of starting material went in and one unit came out. It does not say what the starting material was, which tissue it came from, what solvent was used, or what ended up in the finished powder. Two products can both be labelled 10:1 and contain very different things. The figure that would tell you something is a measured beta-glucan percentage with the analytical method named alongside it, and most labels in this category do not carry one.
Why does fruiting body versus mycelium keep coming up?
Because commercial mycelium is usually grown on sterilised grain and harvested with the grain still in it. Starch is a polysaccharide and a glucan, so grain inflates a total polysaccharide figure. The reference method published by McCleary and Draga in the Journal of AOAC International in 2016 gets round this by measuring starch and glycogen separately and reporting beta-glucan as the difference. If a label gives a polysaccharide number without an alpha-glucan number, that subtraction has not been done.
Which Cordyceps species is in Chaski Cacao?
Cordyceps sinensis, as mycelium. It is not Cordyceps militaris. The distinction is worth checking on any label, because the two are chemically different raw materials: Su and colleagues, in Analytical Methods in 2019, measured 0.735 mg of cordycepin per gram in Cordyceps militaris material and did not detect cordycepin in the Cordyceps sinensis material. That was an analytical study on three replicates of shop-bought samples, not a trial in people.
Sources
- Sung GH et al., Studies in Mycology, 2007
- McCleary BV and Draga A, Journal of AOAC International, 2016
- Vetter J, Foods, 2023
- Su Y et al., Analytical Methods, 2019
- Mori K et al., Phytotherapy Research, 2009