Lion's Mane vs Reishi: Two Very Different Fungi

Lion's Mane and Reishi are two unrelated fungi that happen to share a shelf. Lion's Mane is Hericium erinaceus, a soft white toothed mushroom that fruits on dead hardwood and is cooked and eaten; Reishi is a hard, varnished bracket fungus from the genus Ganoderma, taken as an extract because it is not edible in the ordinary sense.

The honest comparison between them is not about what they do. There are no authorised GB health claims for either, so a "which is better for X" page cannot be written. What can be written, and is more useful at the point of buying, is this: one of these two has a naming problem so severe that the Latin binomial on the pack is frequently wrong, and the other does not.

Reishi is not one agreed species

Almost every Reishi product in Britain says Ganoderma lucidum. For a large share of them, that name is probably incorrect.

Wang and colleagues sequenced three gene regions — ITS, IGS and rpb2 — across cultivated Chinese Ling-zhi and published the result in PLoS ONE in 2012. The cultivated Chinese fungus came out conspecific with Ganoderma sichuanense and separated cleanly in the phylogeny from the English G. lucidum. In other words, the Asian cultivated mushroom and the European species that carries the famous name are not the same organism.

Papp's 2024 review in Fungal Biology Reviews picks up the fallout. It records that G. lucidum is "widely but incorrectly used" for Ling-zhi, including on medicinal products, and notes that Moncalvo and Ryvarden recognised 35 species inside the G. lucidum complex back in 1997, fifteen of which were described before G. sichuanense. Both papers are nomenclatural and neither tested a supplement, so neither tells you what any particular pack of powder contains. That is the point. The literature cannot resolve it, and nor can the label.

Lion's Mane has none of this. Hericium erinaceus means one fungus, it is sold as a culinary mushroom, and when a label names it you can be fairly confident which organism was grown.

Lion's Mane vs Reishi on the things a label can prove

Lion's Mane Reishi
Latin name Hericium erinaceus. Stable. Ganoderma lucidum on the pack; often G. sichuanense or G. lingzhi in fact.
Texture Soft, white, spiny. Cooks like meat. Hard, woody, varnished bracket. Not chewable.
Normal form sold Fresh, dried, powder or extract. Extract or milled powder, effectively always.
Taste in a food Mild, slightly savoury. Markedly bitter.
Number a lab can verify Beta-glucan, by difference. Beta-glucan, by difference.

The measurement problem both of them share

Whichever fungus is on the pack, the figure that would tell you something is a measured beta-glucan percentage. Most labels print a polysaccharide percentage or an extract ratio instead, and neither is the same number; reading a supplement or functional food label is mostly a matter of knowing which number is missing.

McCleary and Draga set out the reference approach in the Journal of AOAC International in 2016. Release total glucan by controlled sulphuric acid hydrolysis, hydrolyse starch and glycogen separately with glucoamylase, and report beta-glucan as the difference between the two. Their paper also found that sulphuric acid gave significantly higher values than hydrochloric for Ganoderma lucidum specifically, which means two laboratories can report different beta-glucan figures for the same Reishi and both be using an accepted method.

Starch is a glucan. Commercial mycelium is usually grown on sterilised grain and harvested with the grain in it. Vetter's 2023 review in Foods reports a shiitake dataset in which mycelium carried the lowest total glucan of the three tissues measured, with a mycelium to cap to stipe ratio of 100 to 161.7 to 199.6, and the highest relative alpha-glucan share. It is a narrative review of other people's data, the mycelium sample size is not given, and shiitake is neither of the mushrooms on this page.

"10:1 extract" does not help either. It is a yield ratio: ten units of starting material in, one unit out. It says nothing about what the starting material was.

What the Lion's Mane trial actually did

Mori and colleagues, Phytotherapy Research, 2009, is the trial most often paraphrased into something it did not say. Thirty Japanese adults aged 50 to 80 with mild cognitive impairment, screened at 22 to 25 out of 30, randomised double-blind against placebo. Twenty-nine completed.

Dose: four 250 mg tablets, three times a day, sixteen weeks. Each tablet was 96% air-dried powdered fruiting body, so roughly 2.9 g of plain powder a day, not a concentrated extract. On the study's 30-point scale the mushroom group scored higher than placebo at weeks 8, 12 and 16, and scores fell back four weeks after dosing stopped.

The authors note the placebo group improved too, and that it is unknown whether the proposed active compounds reach human brain tissue. Twenty-nine people, one country, four months, not replicated at that size, and at a gram-level powder dose that is not comparable to a few hundred milligrams of extract. That is a description of one trial. It is not a statement about any product, and it is not a statement about you. We have not cited a Reishi trial on this page because we have not opened one that meets the same standard here.

What is in a Chaski tube, and what is not

Chaski Cacao contains no Reishi. It is a 600 g tube of 77% dark chocolate buttons, four buttons to the daily dose on the pack, made with single-origin Peruvian and Ecuadorian cacao, low-temperature ground and sweetened with coconut sugar. No emulsifiers, no seed oils, no palm oil, no added cane sugar. Every batch is tested for lead, cadmium and pesticides.

The mushroom ingredients are Lion's Mane as a fruiting body extract and Cordyceps sinensis as mycelium; the species distinction there is set out in Cordyceps sinensis vs militaris. Ginkgo Biloba is being replaced by 200 mg of Tremella fuciformis, a 10:1 fruiting body extract, per daily dose. By our own standard above we owe you one admission: there is no measured beta-glucan figure for Chaski, so we do not print one. A single tube is £44.99 on the Chaski Cacao product page. For dosing conventions see how much Lion's Mane people take, and the rest of the library is at our guides index.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Reishi the same thing as Ganoderma lucidum?

Usually not, despite the label. Wang and colleagues, publishing in PLoS ONE in 2012, sequenced three gene regions across cultivated Chinese Ling-zhi and found it conspecific with Ganoderma sichuanense and distinct from the European Ganoderma lucidum. Papp's 2024 review in Fungal Biology Reviews records that the name G. lucidum is widely but incorrectly used for Ling-zhi, including on medicinal products, and that 35 species were recognised inside the G. lucidum complex as long ago as 1997. Neither paper tested supplements, so neither can tell you what is in a given pack.

Can I just eat Reishi the way I would eat Lion's Mane?

No. Lion's Mane is a soft culinary mushroom that is fried, roasted or shredded like meat, and it is sold fresh in Britain. Reishi is a hard varnished bracket fungus with a woody texture and a markedly bitter taste, which is why it reaches consumers as a milled powder or an extract rather than as something you chew. That difference in physical form is one reason the two are handled completely differently by manufacturers.

Why does Chaski Cacao not contain Reishi?

Chaski is built around single-origin cacao, and every added ingredient has to survive being eaten as chocolate four buttons at a time. Reishi is bitter and woody, and cacao at 77% is already a bitter base. The tube carries Lion's Mane as a fruiting body extract and Cordyceps sinensis as mycelium, with Ginkgo Biloba being replaced by 200 mg of Tremella fuciformis, a 10:1 fruiting body extract, per daily dose. Reishi is not in the recipe and we do not claim it is.

What figure should I look for on a mushroom label?

A measured beta-glucan percentage with the analytical method named, alongside the Latin binomial, the tissue used and the milligram weight per stated daily portion. A polysaccharide percentage is not the same thing, because starch is a polysaccharide and commercial mycelium is usually grown on grain. An extract ratio such as 10:1 describes yield, not composition. Most labels in this category give you one or two of the four things, and the beta-glucan figure is the one most often missing.

Sources

  1. Wang XC et al., PLoS ONE, 2012
  2. Papp V, Fungal Biology Reviews, 2024
  3. McCleary BV and Draga A, Journal of AOAC International, 2016
  4. Vetter J, Foods, 2023
  5. Mori K et al., Phytotherapy Research, 2009
Liquid error (sections/pagefly-section line 6): Could not find asset snippets/pf-6bdf23d6.liquid