Phenylethylamine In Cacao: Separating Myth From Data
Phenylethylamine is genuinely present in cocoa, and the phenylethylamine cacao research is clear about where it comes from: mostly fermentation and roasting, not the fresh bean. What the measurement literature does not do is join that fact to the story usually told about it.
The story runs: cocoa contains phenylethylamine, phenylethylamine is a trace amine found in the brain, therefore chocolate is a love drug. Each step is sourceable. The chain between them is not.
Where the phenylethylamine in cacao comes from
The most direct measurement is Granvogl, Bugan and Schieberle, writing in the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry in 2006. They built an LC-MS-MS method using dansyl chloride derivatisation to quantify five amines, 2-phenylethylamine among them, and applied it to unfermented, fermented and roasted cocoas from Ghana and Sulawesi.
Most of the amines increased during fermentation, which the authors attributed to enzymatic formation from the parent amino acids, phenylalanine in the case of 2-phenylethylamine. Roasting produced a much larger increase again, into the milligrams-per-kilogram range, and the authors proposed a thermal formation route for it. In roasted cocoa, 2-phenylethylamine was far more abundant than its corresponding aldehyde, phenylacetaldehyde, which is the opposite of what their model reactions produced.
Two limits matter. This is an analytical study of beans and nibs, not of finished chocolate, and the published abstract reports the milligrams-per-kilogram figure for the amines as a group rather than giving a single number for 2-phenylethylamine. Only two origins were examined. Read as process chemistry it is solid; read as a dietary intake figure it is not available.
Finished chocolate is harder still. A 2013 review by Irsfeld, Spadafore and Prüß reports that an earlier survey by Pastore and colleagues worked to a detection limit of 3 mg per kilogram and did not find phenylethylamine above it. That is a secondhand citation, but it marks the position: the quantity in a bar sits at or below the edge of routine detection.
What trace-amine pharmacology actually measures
The second half of the story concerns the compound in the body rather than in the bean. Pei, Asif-Malik and Canales reviewed the field in Frontiers in Neuroscience in 2016.
Their review describes trace amines as present in the central nervous system at low nanomolar concentrations, several hundred-fold below the classical neurotransmitters, citing work from 1980 and 2004. It gives a half-life of around 30 seconds for the class. It also notes that monoamine oxidase B inhibitors raised beta-phenylethylamine above its physiological range in animal work, and delayed its deactivation.
Those figures come with caveats. This is a narrative review, not a trial. The nanomolar concentrations and the 30-second half-life are reported for trace amines as a group, not for phenylethylamine specifically. And the review covers endogenous pools and receptor pharmacology; it does not address dietary intake, and its food section concerns tyramine instead.
The controlled experiment that separated cocoa's constituents
One human study did try to work out which of cocoa's compounds account for measurable changes. Smit, Gaffan and Rogers published two double-blind, placebo-controlled studies in Psychopharmacology in 2004, with 20 and 22 participants respectively.
In the first, participants received 11.6 g of cocoa powder, or a combination of 19 mg caffeine and 250 mg theobromine, or placebo. Outcomes were a long-duration simple reaction time task, a rapid visual information processing task and a mood questionnaire. The second study compared the methylxanthine levels found in milk and dark chocolate against white chocolate and water.
The authors reported that cocoa powder and the isolated caffeine-plus-theobromine combination produced the same pattern of scores relative to placebo on the energetic arousal construct and on the cognitive tasks, and that white chocolate did not differ significantly from water. Their own conclusion was that methylxanthines are the psychopharmacologically active constituents, while other attributes of chocolate are probably more important for its appeal.
Twenty and twenty-two participants is small, the record carries no description of the population beyond "participants", and no limitations section is published with the paper. Note also what the design did not do: it never administered phenylethylamine, so it cannot test the phenylethylamine hypothesis either way. It simply shows that a methylxanthine dose reproduced the cocoa result.
Claim against measurement
| Commonly said | What has actually been measured |
|---|---|
| Cacao is rich in phenylethylamine | Amines reach mg/kg in roasted beans (Granvogl 2006); one chocolate survey reported a 3 mg/kg detection limit with no detection above it |
| It is the "love chemical" | Trace amines sit at low nanomolar concentrations in the CNS with a class half-life near 30 seconds (Pei 2016 review) |
| Phenylethylamine explains how chocolate feels | The one study separating constituents tested caffeine and theobromine, not phenylethylamine (Smit 2004) |
| Raw cacao has more of it | Granvogl 2006 found the largest increases during roasting, with fermentation second |
That last row is the interesting one, because it cuts against the raw-cacao framing. If you are following the chain from bean to bloodstream, the related question of how cacao compounds are absorbed is handled separately, as is the question of how single-origin cacao develops its flavour during the same fermentation and roasting steps. The full Chaski guide library indexes both clusters.
What is in a Chaski tube
The sections above describe published measurements on cocoa and on trace-amine pharmacology in general. They are not statements about any product. What follows is a label description.
Chaski Cacao is a 600 g tube of 77 per cent dark chocolate buttons, with a stated daily dose of four buttons. The cacao is single-origin Peruvian and Ecuadorian and is low-temperature ground; the sweetener is coconut sugar. There are no emulsifiers, no seed oils, no palm oil and no added cane sugar, and every batch is tested for lead, cadmium and pesticides.
The mushroom components are Lion's Mane as a fruiting body extract and Cordyceps sinensis as mycelium. The Ginkgo Biloba component is being replaced by 200 mg of Tremella fuciformis, a 10:1 fruiting body extract, per daily dose; that is a change in progress. No phenylethylamine, theobromine or flavanol quantity is published for the tube, because none has been measured. One tube is £44.99 and three tubes are £98.97, which is £32.99 per tube.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much phenylethylamine is in chocolate?
There is no settled figure. Granvogl, Bugan and Schieberle, in the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry in 2006, measured amines in unfermented, fermented and roasted cocoas from Ghana and Sulawesi and reported milligram-per-kilogram levels after roasting, but for the amines as a group rather than as a single phenylethylamine number. For finished chocolate, a 2013 review by Irsfeld and colleagues reports an earlier survey working to a 3 mg per kilogram detection limit without finding it above that threshold. Both are analytical studies of material, not intake measurements.
Is raw cacao higher in phenylethylamine than roasted?
The measurement literature points the other way. Granvogl and colleagues in 2006 found that most of the amines they quantified rose during fermentation, which they attributed to enzymatic formation from parent amino acids, and then rose considerably more during roasting, for which they proposed a thermal pathway. On their data, 2-phenylethylamine in cocoa is substantially a product of processing rather than a constituent of the fresh bean. The study covered two origins and examined beans rather than finished chocolate, so it should not be read as a figure for any particular bar.
What did the trial that separated cocoa's compounds actually test?
Smit, Gaffan and Rogers ran two double-blind, placebo-controlled studies published in Psychopharmacology in 2004, with 20 and 22 participants. One arm received 11.6 g of cocoa powder, another a combination of 19 mg caffeine and 250 mg theobromine, and a third placebo, with reaction time, visual information processing and a mood questionnaire as outcomes. The authors reported that cocoa powder and the methylxanthine combination produced the same pattern of scores against placebo. Phenylethylamine was never administered, so the design cannot test it. The samples were small and no population description is published.
Does Chaski state a phenylethylamine content?
No. Phenylethylamine has not been assayed in the product, so no figure appears on the tube or the product page, and neither does a theobromine or flavanol figure. What is published is composition and process: a 600 g tube of 77 per cent dark buttons, four buttons as the stated daily dose, single-origin Peruvian and Ecuadorian cacao that is low-temperature ground, coconut sugar, Lion's Mane as a fruiting body extract, Cordyceps sinensis as mycelium, no emulsifiers or seed oils or palm oil or added cane sugar, and batch testing for lead, cadmium and pesticides.
Sources
- Granvogl M, Bugan S and Schieberle P, Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 2006
- Pei Y, Asif-Malik A and Canales J J, Frontiers in Neuroscience, 2016
- Smit H J, Gaffan E A and Rogers P J, Psychopharmacology, 2004
- Irsfeld M, Spadafore M and Prüß B M, Webmedcentral, 2013
See what is printed on the tube
Chaski Cacao — 600 g tube, 77% dark, single-origin cacao, low-temperature ground