Cacao vs Carob: What Actually Differs
Carob is the roasted, ground pod of Ceratonia siliqua, a Mediterranean tree. Cacao is the fermented, roasted seed of Theobroma cacao, a tropical one. They are not related, they do not taste alike, and the numbers on the back of the pack are not close: USDA FoodData Central lists carob flour at 49.1 g of total sugars and 0.65 g of fat per 100 g, against 1.75 g of sugars and 13.7 g of fat for unsweetened cocoa powder.
Carob is naturally sweet and almost fat-free. Cacao is bitter and roughly a seventh fat even after pressing. Every practical difference between them, in a mug or in a cake tin, comes out of those two facts.
The two composition tables, side by side
| Per 100 g | Carob flour | Cocoa powder, unsweetened |
|---|---|---|
| Energy | 222 kcal | 228 kcal |
| Protein | 4.62 g | 19.6 g |
| Fat | 0.65 g | 13.7 g |
| Total sugars | 49.1 g | 1.75 g |
| Fibre | 39.8 g | 37.0 g |
| Calcium | 348 mg | Not listed on this page |
| Magnesium | 54 mg | 499 mg |
| Theobromine | 0.0 mg | 2060 mg |
| Caffeine | 0.0 mg | 230 mg |
Both figures come from USDA FoodData Central records for the commodity. They are not figures for any finished product, ours included.
The theobromine row is the one people buy carob for. The USDA record lists it at zero, along with caffeine. Cacao's record lists both. That is a composition difference, and this page is not going to tell you what either compound does to you.
Why carob tastes sweet and cacao does not
Carob pods are nearly half sugar by weight before anybody adds anything, mostly sucrose laid down in the pulp. Roasting caramelises some of it and gives the flour its malty, slightly raisin-like smell. Nothing in carob is bitter in the way cacao is, because the alkaloids and the polyphenol load that make cacao bitter are not there.
Cacao arrives at bitterness honestly: fermentation, roasting and a seed that is defended chemically. A 77% bar is bitter because 77% of it is cacao. That is why chocolate makers add sugar, and why a carob maker often does not need to.
The fat question, and where palm creeps in
Here is the tension the category does not advertise. Carob flour has almost no fat, 0.65 g per 100 g, so a carob bar cannot be made the way a chocolate bar is made. There is no carob butter to melt and set. The fat has to come from somewhere else.
Look at what it is. The USDA record for unsweetened carob candy lists 31.4 g of fat per 100 g, of which 17.6 g is lauric acid and 6.26 g is myristic acid. Carob flour contributes 0.65 g of fat per 100 g, so essentially all of that fat was added during manufacture, and lauric and myristic acids are the signature of palm kernel and coconut fats rather than of cocoa butter.
None of that makes carob bad. It makes the comparison honest: a carob bar is a flour plus a bought-in fat, and a dark chocolate button is a seed whose own fat has never left it. Chaski uses no palm oil and no seed oil, and the only fat in the tube is the cocoa butter that came with the bean.
Cacao vs carob in the kitchen
Swapping one for the other is not a like-for-like substitution, whatever a recipe card says. Carob brings about 49 g of sugar per 100 g with it, so a cake made with carob and the sugar quantity written for cocoa comes out markedly sweeter. Carob also scorches sooner than cocoa, so a hot oven or a dry pan will take it from malty to acrid quickly.
Going the other way is just as awkward: replace carob with cocoa and you have removed most of the sweetness and added bitterness, fat and a different colour. Our guide to substituting cacao in baking works through the ratios properly.
In a drink, the difference is texture. Carob dissolves into a thin, sweet, malty liquid. Cacao carries fat, so it builds body, and if you use buttons rather than a powder the fat emulsifies as the disc melts. The nibs, powder and buttons comparison covers which cacao format mixes most easily.
What the label can and cannot say
The reserved descriptions in Schedule 1 of The Cocoa and Chocolate Products (England) Regulations 2003 - chocolate, milk chocolate, white chocolate, cocoa powder, fat-reduced cocoa and the rest - are tied to cocoa materials. A carob product sits outside those categories, which is why carob bars are sold as carob bars and not as chocolate.
So when you see the two next to each other, read the ingredient list rather than the shelf label. For a carob product, the questions are which fat was added and how much sugar beyond the pod's own. For a cacao product, the questions are the cocoa percentage, the sweetener and whether the maker publishes anything about origin and testing.
What is in a Chaski tube
Chaski Cacao is a 600 g tube of 77% dark buttons. Single-origin cacao from Peru and Ecuador, ground at low temperature, sweetened with coconut sugar. No added cane sugar, no emulsifier, no palm oil, no seed oil. Lion's Mane is included as a fruiting body extract, Cordyceps as sinensis mycelium, and Ginkgo Biloba is being replaced by 200 mg Tremella fuciformis (10:1 fruiting body extract) per daily dose, so read the panel on the batch you receive.
Every batch is tested for lead, cadmium and pesticides. The dose on the pack is four buttons. A tube is £44.99 with a 30-day money-back guarantee, and UK orders placed before 4pm go out the same day. If caffeine and theobromine are what you are avoiding, Chaski is not the product for you, and we would rather say so than sell you a tube you return.
Other comparisons in this series are indexed on the Chaski guides page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is carob a good replacement for cacao?
It depends on what you are replacing. As a colour and a malty flavour in baking, carob works. As a substitute for the structure and bitterness of cacao, it does not, because the compositions are far apart: USDA lists carob flour at 49.1 g sugars and 0.65 g fat per 100 g against 1.75 g sugars and 13.7 g fat for unsweetened cocoa powder. Swap one for the other without adjusting sugar and fat and the recipe will not behave.
Does carob contain caffeine or theobromine?
The USDA FoodData Central record for carob flour lists both caffeine and theobromine at 0.0 mg per 100 g. The record for unsweetened cocoa powder lists 230 mg of caffeine and 2060 mg of theobromine per 100 g. That is a straightforward composition difference between the two foods, and it is the usual reason people reach for carob. We make no statement here about what either compound does.
Why do carob bars contain palm or coconut fat?
Because carob has almost no fat of its own. Carob flour is 0.65 g of fat per 100 g, so there is no carob equivalent of cocoa butter to set a bar. The USDA record for unsweetened carob candy shows 31.4 g of fat per 100 g, including 17.6 g lauric acid and 6.26 g myristic acid, which is the fatty acid signature of palm kernel and coconut fats rather than cocoa butter. Almost all of that fat was added during manufacture.
Can a carob bar be labelled as chocolate in the UK?
No. The reserved descriptions in Schedule 1 of The Cocoa and Chocolate Products (England) Regulations 2003 cover cocoa butter, cocoa powder, fat-reduced cocoa and the chocolate categories, and they are defined in terms of cocoa materials. A product made from carob pod flour does not meet them, which is why carob bars are sold under their own name. Read the ingredient list for the added fat and sugar rather than the shelf label.
Is carob sweeter than cacao?
Considerably, before anyone adds anything. USDA lists carob flour at 49.1 g of total sugars per 100 g, mostly from the pod pulp, against 1.75 g for unsweetened cocoa powder. That is why carob products often carry less added sugar and why carob tastes malty rather than bitter. It also means a recipe written for cocoa will come out sweeter if you swap carob in without cutting the sugar.
Sources
- US Department of Agriculture, FoodData Central, SR Legacy 173755, Carob flour
- US Department of Agriculture, FoodData Central, SR Legacy 169593, Cocoa, dry powder, unsweetened
- US Department of Agriculture, FoodData Central, SR Legacy 167973, Candies, carob, unsweetened
- The Cocoa and Chocolate Products (England) Regulations 2003, SI 2003/1659, Schedule 1